11 Creative Ways to Pick Teams or Groups in the Classroom

A picture of 5 young kids sitting on the ground with their hands up. Text reads 11 creative ways to pick teams or groups in the classroom.

Choosing teams can be almost as important as the game you are actually playing.

You want your teams to be an even match. A game where one team is significantly better than the other is not much fun for the losing team.

Having control over who is on what team is a good way for a facilitator to maintain control of the group. You can split up two kids who are likely to mess around if they are together, ensure that the teams have even ability, and make sure that your students are learning to work with all other students, not just their friends.

Consider the Following Team Choosing Methods

1. Counting Off Numbers

Children line-up and you count off: 1-2, 1-2, 1-2, etc.; for variation use Colors: Red-Blue, Red-Blue, etc. (Caution: Watch to make sure kids don’t position themselves to get a “certain” number or color to be on their Team of choice.)

This method works well when you want to have a quick system or split up two students but want team selection to seem random.

2. Children Decide

If you have a group where the students are all of the similar abilities and get along with each other, then you can let them pick their own teams. This is a good method when you want the kids to feel as though they have control of the program. Caution: Watch that no feelings get hurt. This method works well-only when skills are even; otherwise, avoid it.

3. Staff Decides

When you want to maintain complete control over the teams, you can decide who is on what team. Youth seldom complain about this method, when you explain that you want the teams to be evenly matched because of all the different grades.

4. Draw Straws

This is good when you have students of similar ability and want to choose teams with controlled randomness. Take Popsicle or chop sticks and put different colors of electrical tape or paint around the end.

Hold them in your hand or container so that students cannot see the colors.  Have each of the students pick a stick; they then separate into teams based on the color of their stick.

5. Rock, Paper, Scissors

This method is fun if you don’t have a large group and also have longer playing time. It also works well when you have students of similar abilities and you want the teams chosen with student-controlled randomness.

Students play rock, paper, scissors, but without the scissors, so they can only throw rock or paper. Pair off the kids and they keep doing this until there is an even number of rocks and papers for your two teams.

  • Don’t forget about Rock, Paper, Scissors to settle “who goes first” with two people!
  • Flipping a coin (heads or tails) also works well.

6. Top Draft Picks

Let captains choose some players for their teams and have game facilitator place the rest of the children on the teams so that no one is chosen last! The kids won’t complain and teams are usually pretty fair because all of the better athletes are split up early.

Looking for Team Captains? Who Goes First?? Who Chooses a Game? Etc.

7. Guess the Number 

The leader picks a number within a range and youth try to guess the number. Example: Leader says, “I’m thinking of a number between 1 and 50”. The child closest to the number is the winner.

Need to Get a Certain Number of Kids-into a Certain Number of Groups?

8. Use Number Pops

Write numbers on craft or Popsicle sticks; these numbers should correlate to the number of groups you would like to have and the number of kids in each group.

  • Example: If you want six groups of four students, then write four 1’s, four 2’s and so on.
  • You can also write numbers on containers to separate your groups into sizes of 4, 5, and 6.
  • Good to use with activities where your participants are limited in numbers such as cooking with kids, making play dough, goop, etc. Have children pick their stick to see with which group they will cook or do a science project. No more of “That’s not fair.”

Note: It will take a little work to prepare the sticks-but once you do them they’re done! I did some for sample purposes. I bought colored sticks and it only took about 15 minutes to get them done.

I still use a similar method with my grandchildren to see who chooses first. It’s almost like magic! Hold straws or sticks-with one that is shortened. The kids just don’t argue with a short straw or stick.

9. Find a partner

The next time you need children to find a partner, try this approach from Marlene Kliman and Martha Merson of Mixing in Math. You’ll mix up social groups and get children involved in measuring at the same time.

Instead of asking children to line up in pairs, ask them to find a partner who has something in common with them, for instance:

  • Find a partner with the same length index finger as yours.
  • Find a partner with the same arm span as yours.
  • Find a partner whose feet are as long as yours.

Children pair up with the first person they find who has the same measurement. Anyone who can’t find a partner joins the person or pair who comes closest.

10. Jelly roll

“Jelly Roll’ can be used when you need to group up kids, sit them down, have a meeting, explain something, etc.

To Start: Previously, assign your large group a method to get them into smaller groups, this can be done by assigning each individual small group a color, season, number, animal, etc.

  • Call “Jelly-Roll” and the kids get into their small groups.
  • Have each small group hold hands in one long line and then roll from one end to the other into a “jelly roll” and then sit down.
  • Time youth to see which group can “Roll” and sit the fastest, and then see if they can “beat” their best time. At first, this may be confusing but when the kids get the routine down it will go quickly. Just practice, practice, practice. All you need to do is yell “Jelly Roll”…and then they do their thing!

This is a great way to divide children into two teams. Players close their eyes while one person taps them on their shoulders and designates them either a “duck” or “cow.”

On a given signal, keeping their eyes closed, the players must make their animal sounds to gather into their two teams. The ducks “quack” and the cows “moo.” When the two groups all “find each other, begin your game.

11. Ducks and Cows (For a game that needs two teams…)

To go along with a Farm or Harvest theme, this is a great way to divide children into two teams. Players close their eyes while one person taps them on their shoulders and designates them either a “duck” or “cow.”

On a given signal, keeping their eyes closed – the players must make their animal sounds to gather into their two teams. The ducks “quack” and the cows “moo.” When the two groups all “find each other – begin your game.

Selecting Teams is a Transition~You may also be interested in:

A Pinterest image with two pictures one of a young girl looking at a young boy smiling and another with 5 young kids with their hands up. Text reads How to be fair in picking teams in the classroom.